Fluid vs Magnetic Bicycle Trainers: What for and How to Choose the Best One?
Bike Trainer Fluid vs Magnetic: All You Need to Know!
Many athletes in winter wonder – how do cyclists prepare for the summer racing season? The answer is simple: in addition to general physical training in the gym and various activities (running, skiing), cyclists “spend the winter” at the bike trainer. When it comes to ordinary riding, it is possible to ride a bike year-round, but with the rules of preparation of the bike and the selection of equipment. If we consider winter as a special training plan, however, cold conditions are not always suitable for quality training.
One inexpensive solution, in this case, is to buy a bike trainer, in which you can mount the bike and start training. Its main function is to create resistance to the rear wheel, simulating a real ride on the street. Do you want to lose weight, tighten your buttocks and thighs, develop endurance and improve the cardiovascular system, but do not have time to go to the gym? Pay attention to modern exercise bike trainers for home, which will help you to strengthen the muscles of the lower body, improve your health and emotional state, increase vitality and get rid of stress. Exercising a bicycle is a great option for working out at home. Those people who enjoy a regular bicycle and riding on the streets or free natural areas see no reason to buy an exercise bike. On the other hand, when the weather clouds up, and you want to ride, you may wonder what to do. That’s where the bike trainer, a device that allows you to turn a simple bicycle into an exercise bike at home, comes to the rescue.
So, a bicycle trainer is a special device with which you can pedal your favorite bicycle without leaving your favorite apartment. A cycling trainer allows you to adjust the load, choose the nature of the workout, is cheaper than a full-fledged exercise bike (not always the case) and takes up little space. Once you start to search the Internet, you understand that there are dozens of bike trainers and a lot of types. Which one to choose? What to pay attention to? Today we will talk about the two best options: magnetic trainer bike and fluid trainer bike.
Here are a couple of key factors to consider when choosing a cycling machine.
- First: the noise level. Although some machines are advertised or positioned as silent, they are all, to a greater or lesser extent, noisy. So, when you purchase a cycle trainer from a store, try it out for the level of noise it makes, if possible, before you buy it. Every person is different and your level of acceptable noise may be completely different from the next or previous buyer. So reviews of other people will not work for you. Remember that noisy exercise bike trainers can bring more unpleasant emotions than the whole endeavor is worth, and you may end up giving exercising after a short time.
- Second: what are the impressions you experience on the cycling trainer? The goal is to feel as realistic as possible about what you’re riding on the road. If the bicycle trainer doesn’t give you even a remote feeling of real riding, reminding you of how great it is to ride a bike – will you use it for long? Probably not.
- Third: stability. No one would want to fall with a trainer during a sprint, so assess how stable the machine’s platform is. If the platform is narrow, the likelihood of a crash is higher.
- Fourth: smart features. Do you remember how monotonous and excruciatingly long time passes on a treadmill at the gym or on a stationary bicycle? To pedal at home was not so boring, think about getting a more expensive bike trainer, but with smart functions. Such a trainer will connect to a special program, will simulate climbs and descents, automatically set you a training interval, and will show all your data: heart rate, cadence, power.
No matter how attractive it looks, no matter how inexpensive it is, you should always keep these two points in mind when deciding to buy a bike training station. The perfect balance is achieved when you find a bike trainer that fits your budget, does not make your dog howl under the couch because of its noise and reminds you of how great it is to ride a bike. All this will help you stay in shape and get ready for the season ahead.
Magnetic Bike Trainer Review
The magnetic indoor bike trainer is a great option for those who want to stay in shape during the winter months and are just starting their cycling journey. It is based on a small metal flywheel, around which there is a series of magnets that create resistance when rotating. Several magnets are used to resist the wheel. When you buy such a magnetic resistance bike trainer in the medium to high price range, there is the possibility of adjusting the loads. Through manual adjustment, you can set the right resistance for specific purposes, whether it’s simulated uphill riding or flat runs.
Due to their simple design, these cycling machines are considered extremely reliable and durable. The disadvantages of the indoor magnetic bike trainer include increasing noise as the flywheel speed increases, as well as the resistance limit (the higher the resistance – the more expensive the bike trainer). The bike trainer magnetic is generally quiet.
The electromagnets can be linear (unchangeable) and variable (this one you need to charge). It has 7-10 levels of difficulty, which can be switched either directly on the handwheel or remotely (a special optional handlebar-mounted handwheel). If you know for sure that you need the best magnetic bike trainer, then we can recommend you to buy the Wahoo KICKR Core Smart Trainer, which is considered to be the best option for indoor training.
Bike Fluid Trainer Review
Kinetic or fluid indoor bike trainers are similar in structure to magnetic machines, but instead of a flywheel and magnets, there is an impeller and a series of stationary blades inside the mechanism. The fluid inside is accelerated by the rotating impeller, while the stationary blades create a reverse resistance. The faster the bicycle wheel spins and the faster the speed of the impeller, the greater the resistance. By doing so, such a design simulates real riding on the street, when it becomes harder to pedal as the speed increases. Among the disadvantages of such indoor bike fluid trainers are their high cost and the possibility of fluid overheating during intensive use.
The fact is that this kinetic fluid bike trainer is the quietest and most expensive type of cycling trainer. Has a progressive resistance: the faster you rotate the cranks, the higher the resistance. This kind of trainer is ideal for interval training. A fluid cycling trainer uses synthetic silicone oils. They are resistant to heat, so the viscosity of the fluid remains constant throughout the life of the device. Combined with the voluminous flywheel, the best fluid bike trainer gives you the most realistic riding experience. Especially for you, we have done the fluid bike trainers comparison and have chosen the best option, which is the Premium Steel Design bike trainer by Yaheetech for indoor training.
Fluid vs Magnetic Bicycle Trainer: Which One Is Better?
If you have decided to buy a trainer, then you face the question: which trainer is better: magnetic vs fluid bike trainer? And is there any difference between them for amateur cyclists?
As we have already written, the magnetic trainer uses special magnets for resistance to slow down the wheel. The fluid trainer uses special impellers with oiled fluid for the same function. Both use a hub to connect your bicycle to the trainer. But here the similarities end and the obvious fact is that the fluid trainer is much better because compared to the magnetic version, it makes much less noise. Magnetic trainers are designed so that spinning pedals silently is almost impossible, and if you choose an expensive and high-quality fluid trainer you can avoid headaches from the annoying noise.
Believe us, the noise from the trainer is very destabilizing and distracting from intensive training. Excessive noise will make you think, is it even worth starting a workout if it only gives you a headache?
Another important advantage of the fluid trainer vs magnetic trainer is that with the fluid trainer you will have a smoother bike ride, almost the same as when riding on the track. It also gives you more progressive resistance and improves your load level. When you use a magnetic trainer, you don’t feel a smooth ride, and when you shift gears, it feels like you’re hitting a wall. It is not a good feeling. But fluid trainers are much more expensive than magnetic ones, which should also be considered when choosing.
In our article, you learned all about the two types of bicycle trainers and what is the difference between them. We hope this article will help you with your choice! To make sure you don’t miss our next articles, follow our blog!
- We see you like it! We hope to have a feedback from you!
- We know you did not like it but at least tell why :(
What Is an Enduro Mountain Bike? Picking the Best Enduro Bike
The mountain bike market is constantly changing, as the field of those bikes is rapidly evolving. As a result, trail...
Bike Pinion Gearbox: Pros and Cons of Buying Pinion for Your Bicycle
In 2010, the first Pinion gearbox bike was installed on a bike that rode the Himalayas. By 2012, at the...